Skip to main content

Trade Value and Negotiation

Steve from FanPoolHQ · 2026-10-13

On this page

My rule for trades: in a two-for-one, the side that gets the best player usually wins. Depth comes back off the waiver wire for free. Stars don't. This guide shows the math with real 2025-26 NHL numbers, then covers the cases where the rule breaks.

The most common trade offer in fantasy hockey goes like this. One manager offers two good players for one great one, and the total points look about even, so it feels fair. It usually isn't. The manager who takes the great player almost always comes out ahead, and the reason is the roster spot.

The assumptions

Everything below uses a plain setup, so you can redo it for your own league:

  • 10 teams, each rostering 12 forwards, 6 defencemen and 2 goalies.
  • Points scoring: one point per goal, one per assist.
  • Full 2025-26 regular-season totals from the NHL's official stats.

With 10 teams and 12 forwards each, 120 forwards are on rosters. The best forward left over is your replacement level, the player you can add for free. In 2025-26 the 121st-best forward scored 48 points. Six forwards finished at exactly 48, among them Taylor Hall and Brock Boeser. That's the number that decides two-for-one trades.

A worked forward example

Say you own Nico Hischier and Bryan Rust, and another manager owns Nikita Kucherov. Hischier had 66 points in 82 games last season. Rust had 65 in 72. Kucherov had 130 in 76. Two players for one, 131 points against 130. On paper, a coin flip.

Now count the roster spots. The Kucherov side gives up one spot and gets two players back, so somebody gets cut. The side that receives Kucherov sends two players out, takes one in, and has an open spot to fill off the waiver wire with a 48-point forward.

Two roster spotsSide that gets KucherovSide that gets two
Player 1Nikita Kucherov, 130Nico Hischier, 66
Player 2Waiver forward, 48Bryan Rust, 65
Total178131

That's a 47-point gap from a trade that looked even.

Two honest caveats. First, the 48 is hindsight. In October you don't know who will finish 121st, and real waiver pickups usually fall short of that. Cut the waiver player to 24 points and the Kucherov side still finishes 154 to 131. Second, Kucherov missed six games last year. At his rate of about 1.71 points a game, he would have had to miss roughly 28 more, a third of the season, before the two-for-one side caught up, and that assumes you leave his spot empty the whole time.

Deeper leagues shrink the gap but don't close it. In a 16-team league with 12 forwards each, 192 forwards are rostered and the next one, Teuvo Teravainen, had 35 points. Kucherov plus 35 is 165, still 34 points ahead.

The same math on defence

Defence runs thinner, so the gap is smaller in points but just as real. Sixty defencemen are rostered in our setup. The 61st-best had 31 points in 2025-26, and six defencemen were tied at that mark.

Two roster spotsSide that gets BouchardSide that gets two
Player 1Evan Bouchard, 95Filip Hronek, 49
Player 2Waiver defenceman, 31Noah Dobson, 47
Total12696

Bouchard led all defencemen with 95 points. Hronek and Dobson were 23rd and 25th. Their 96 points beat Bouchard by one, and the trade still costs the two-player side 30 points once the open spot is filled.

When the two-for-one side wins

The rule says "usually". Here are the cases where I'd take the two players.

The star can't stay on the ice. The worked example breaks if the star misses a third of the season or more. History matters here. Matthew Tkachuk played 31 games in 2025-26. If a player has a pattern of missing big chunks of the year, the math above is too generous to him.

The star is already hurt, and you're buying. This one cuts the other way. Aleksander Barkov lost all of 2025-26 to a knee injury that ended in surgery, and on 6 October Florida said his new injury will keep him out six to eight weeks, with no surgery. That still leaves him around 60 games. If his manager is frustrated, two mid-level forwards for Barkov puts you on the winning side of the rule once he's back. Stash him in a reserve slot while you wait.

You have a hole you can't fill. If your league is so deep that the waiver wire is empty at a position, the replacement number drops toward zero, and two real players fill two real holes. Goaltending is where this happens most. With only 2 goalies per team, some leagues leave nothing worth starting on the wire.

You can't use the open spot. FanPoolHQ leagues can cap roster moves per month. If you've already used your changes, the free spot sits empty until the next month, and every week it's empty costs you the 48-point player's production. Check your limit before you accept.

Your roster is already full of stars. If you have more good players than active slots, a third star sits in your reserve doing nothing. Then two mid players who both start can be worth more.

Getting the deal done

The math tells you which side of a two-for-one to be on. Getting the other manager to agree is a separate job.

Target the manager whose roster is thin, the one with injured players or an empty slot. To him, two players fill two holes and the trade really does help. That's an offer he can accept with a straight face, and it's the only kind that gets accepted.

Lead with a fair offer. If you're asking for the star, offer two players whose combined points are a little above his. The other manager will look at the totals first. Let him.

Don't hide the reason. Write one line in the trade note about what the deal does for his team: "you get a second-line centre and a top-six winger for the injured spot." That does more than haggling.

Watch the calendar. Early in the season nobody wants to sell their best player. By the trade deadline, managers out of the race will move a star for depth that helps them next year, especially in keeper leagues.

To send the offer itself, see Trades: propose and respond. If draft picks are part of the package, Trading draft picks covers how they move. Terms like replacement level and VORP are in the fantasy hockey glossary.