Skip to main content

Building a Balanced Roster

Steve from FanPoolHQ · 2026-10-13

On this page

My take: forwards carry a fantasy roster. Spend your premium picks and dollars on forwards, then build your defence and goaltending from what is left. The numbers below are from the NHL's official stats for the 2025-26 regular season, with 2024-25 for comparison. They assume a 10-team points league (one point per goal, one per assist) using FanPoolHQ's default limits of 12 forwards, 6 defencemen and 2 goalies. Your commissioner can change those limits, and the math moves with them.

A balanced roster sounds like one with a star at every position. In practice it is one that puts its best assets where the points are, and in hockey the points are up front. Here is what the 2025-26 season says about that, including the places where it pushes back.

The points are at forward

Sort every NHL skater from 2025-26 by points and count positions:

Top N scorersForwardsDefencemen
Top 10100
Top 25232
Top 50446
Top 1008416

The year before was even more lopsided: 47 forwards in the top 50, and 89 in the top 100.

Now think about what a 10-team league rosters at our default limits: 120 forwards, 60 defencemen and 20 goalies. In 2025-26 the top 120 forwards scored 8,169 points between them and the top 60 defencemen scored 2,816. That is 74% of your skater points coming from forwards. Your forward group decides where you finish.

Where each position runs out

The useful question is how fast each position drops off as the league fills its rosters. Here is the scoring at each rank within the position in 2025-26:

Rank at positionForwardPointsDefencemanPoints
1stConnor McDavid138Evan Bouchard95
6thNick Suzuki101Rasmus Dahlin74
12thJack Eichel90Moritz Seider60
24thMitch Marner80Rasmus Andersson47
36thJuraj Slafkovský73Mike Matheson37
60thPavel Zacha65Jordan Spence31
120thChandler Stephenson49

Two things stand out. The biggest drop at forward is at the very top: from McDavid to the 12th forward is 48 points, and from the 12th to the 36th is only 17 more. The first round is where forwards separate from each other. And the forward depth is real. Stephenson, the last forward rostered in a 10-team league, scored 49 points, and only 23 defencemen matched or beat that. Taylor Hall, the 121st forward and the first one left on waivers, scored 48, one more than the 24th defenceman.

Spend the first round on forwards

That steep top end is why your first pick should be a forward. All ten of the top ten scorers were forwards in 2025-26. McDavid, Nikita Kucherov (130), Nathan MacKinnon (127) and Macklin Celebrini (115) finished 66 to 89 points ahead of the 120th forward.

Forwards also hold their place better. Of the 120 forwards a 10-team league would have rostered off 2024-25 scoring, 89 (74%) were still inside the top 120 a year later. Of the 60 defencemen, 38 (63%) were still in the top 60. When you pay a premium price, you want the position that pays you back again the next year more often.

The exception: elite defencemen

This is where the data argues with me, and it is worth listening. Defencemen are measured against a much lower floor. The 60th defenceman scored 31 points, so Bouchard's 95 put him 64 points above what you could find for free. That is more than Leon Draisaitl's margin over the 120th forward (97 against 49). Measured that way, six defencemen ranked among the top 20 skaters in 2025-26: Bouchard, Zach Werenski (81), Cale Makar (79), Lane Hutson (78), Quinn Hughes (76) and Dahlin (74). The top group also repeats. Five of the six highest-scoring defencemen of 2024-25 were in the top six again. The one who wasn't, Victor Hedman, played 33 games and scored 17 points.

So the rule is narrower than "never take a defenceman early." Take an elite defenceman when he is the best player left on your board, measured against the free player at his position. Don't take one because you feel you need a defenceman. Past that top half-dozen, the case gets thinner. In 2025-26 the 12th defenceman (60 points) sat 29 points above replacement and the 36th forward (73) sat 24 above. In 2024-25 they were level, 23 against 24. When it is that close, take the forward, because he is the one more likely to repeat.

One more caution: 2025-26 was a big year for defencemen. Seven reached 70 points, against three in 2024-25. Don't draft as if that is the new normal.

Take what's left in goal, but take starters

Goalie numbers do not hold from one season to the next. Of the ten goalies with the most wins in 2024-25 (minimum 25 starts), four were in the top ten again in 2025-26. Connor Hellebuyck went from 47 wins and a .925 save percentage to 23 wins and .895, 30th of the 53 goalies with 25 or more starts. Adin Hill went from 32 wins to 10. Paying a first-round price for that kind of swing is how a season starts in a hole.

The spread is also narrower than it feels on draft day. In 2025-26, four goalies tied for fourth in wins with 31. The goalie 20th in wins, Dustin Wolf, had 23.

What's left still has a floor. Only 18 goalies started 50 or more games last season, and a 10-team league rosters 20. In a league where you set a lineup, your goalie plays whether he is good or not, which is why we warned against waiting too long before opening night. Don't spend a premium pick on a goalie, and don't be the last team without two starters. Get both in the middle rounds.

Build the rest around volume

  • Fill the bottom of your forward group with games played. The 36th forward scored 73 points and the 60th scored 65, a gap of eight points over a full season. Pick the player whose team plays on the nights you need bodies.
  • Accept late defencemen. The 24th defenceman scored 47 and the 60th scored 31, about one point every five games. You can live with that in your bottom defence spots if your forwards are good.
  • Check your league's scoring first. Leagues that score hits, blocks or shots change the defence math. For a split tuned to best ball, see Why I Draft Ten Forwards.

Where the numbers come from: the NHL stats API (api.nhle.com), skater and goalie summaries for the 2025-26 and 2024-25 regular seasons. Forwards are players listed at C, LW or RW. Replacement means the 120th forward and the 60th defenceman by points, the last ones rostered in a 10-team league with 12 forwards and 6 defencemen per team. Goalie rankings include only goalies with at least 25 starts.