Skip to main content

Keeper and Dynasty League Strategy

Steve from FanPoolHQ · 2026-10-13

On this page

My rule for keeper and dynasty leagues is simple: age and upside beat production now. A 22-year-old on the way up is worth more to me than a 32-year-old at his peak, even when the veteran scores more this season. The numbers below are why.

In a keeper league you carry a few players from one season to the next. In a dynasty league you keep most or all of your roster for as long as you like. Either way, you are buying several seasons of a player, so the question to ask is who will still be scoring two and three years from now. All stats here come from the NHL's official regular-season numbers. Ages are as of February 1 of each season.

Same points today, different futures

I took the top 50 scorers in two recent seasons, ties included, and checked who was still in the top 50 three seasons later.

Starting seasonAge groupPlayersAverage P/GP that yearStill top 50 three years later
2021-2225 or younger201.1214 (70%)
2021-2230 or older161.125 (31%)
2022-2325 or younger171.1110 (59%)
2022-2330 or older151.013 (20%)

Look at the 2021-22 rows. The young group and the veteran group both averaged 1.12 points per game that season. Three years later, 14 of the 20 young players were still top-50 scorers. Five of the 16 veterans were. Across both seasons, that is 24 of 37 young players (65%) against 8 of 31 veterans (26%).

When you keep a player, you pay for the years ahead, and a 30-year-old's years ahead are worth a lot less than his stat line says.

What the slide looks like

Here are four players who were 32 or older and top-50 scorers in 2022-23, and where they were in 2025-26:

PlayerAge in 2022-232022-232025-26
Erik Karlsson32101 points in 82 games66 points in 75 games
Steven Stamkos3284 in 8166 in 82
Claude Giroux3579 in 8249 in 82
Anze Kopitar3574 in 8238 in 67

Karlsson went from 1.23 points per game to 0.88. Giroux went from 0.96 to 0.60. If you kept any of them for three years on the strength of 2022-23, you paid a top price for a player who became a mid-roster piece.

What the climb looks like

Now the other direction. In 2022-23, Nick Suzuki was 23 and scored 66 points in 82 games. Matt Boldy was 21 and scored 63. Neither looked like a star. In 2025-26, Suzuki had 101 points and Boldy had 85 in 76 games. A manager who kept them at 2022-23 prices got first-line production for depth cost.

The current crop is moving the same way:

PlayerAge in 2025-26Points per game by season
Macklin Celebrini190.90, then 1.40
Wyatt Johnston220.50, 0.79, 0.87, 1.05
Juraj Slafkovsky210.61, 0.65, 0.89 (full seasons only)
Lane Hutson210.80, then 0.95
Connor Bedard200.90, 0.82, 1.09

Celebrini scored 115 points in 2025-26, fourth in the league, in only his second NHL season. Johnston has gone up every single year. Hutson scored 78 points as a 21-year-old defenceman, and he was the 62nd pick of the 2022 draft. Matthew Schaefer, the first overall pick in 2025, put up 59 points in 82 games as an 18-year-old defenceman in his first season.

Not every young player climbs

Upside is a bet, and some bets lose. Matvei Michkov scored 63 points as a rookie in 2024-25 (0.79 per game), then dropped to 51 points in 81 games (0.63) in 2025-26. Lucas Raymond went 0.88, 0.98, 0.95 over the last three seasons, which is very good but flat. Bedard's second season was worse than his first before he jumped in his third.

So I do not hold every 21-year-old forever. I buy the young players who are already producing at a real NHL level, or who are clearly gaining ground year over year, and I give a stalled prospect about two seasons before I move him. Even in the first table, 13 of the 37 young top-50 scorers fell out within three years. Youth improves your odds, and that is all it does.

When production now is the right call

Veterans still score. In 2025-26, 12 of the top 50 scorers were 30 or older. Nikita Kucherov had 130 points at 32. Mark Scheifele set a career high with 103 at 32. Mark Stone posted the best points-per-game rate of his career at 33: 73 points in 60 games, or 1.22.

If your team is good enough to win this season, those players are exactly who you want, and the market often helps you. Dynasty managers who share my rule tend to price a 32-year-old below his output, so a contender can often buy a veteran scorer for less than his production is worth. Just buy him for the title run and expect to get little back when you sell. If you are not contending, that same veteran is the first player I would trade, while his points still look great on paper.

Cost still matters

Everything above assumes the price of keeping a player is fair. In a league where keepers cost a draft pick or count against a cap, a keeper's value is what he produces minus what he costs. A young scorer you can keep for a late-round price is the best asset in the format. A veteran who costs a first-rounder needs to be elite to be worth it. For how cap hits change the math, see the salary cap strategy guide and The Contract Year Is Worth 1.8 Points.

How I run a dynasty roster

  • Trade veterans a year early. By the time a 32-year-old's decline shows up in his stats, his trade value has already dropped with it.
  • Buy before the jump. Celebrini, Bedard and Johnston all made their biggest move after their first or second year. A young player coming off a quiet season costs less than one coming off a breakout.
  • Do not skip young defencemen. Hutson had 78 points at 21 and Schaefer had 59 at 18. A defenceman who produces that early can anchor a blue line for years.
  • Pick a lane. Contend with veterans or rebuild with youth. A roster of 31-year-olds that cannot win this year is the worst place to be.

If any of the terms here are new, the fantasy hockey glossary covers them, and trade value and negotiation covers how to sell a veteran before the market catches up.