Skip to main content

Draft Strategy Fundamentals

Steve from FanPoolHQ · 2026-10-13

On this page

The rule this guide is built on: draft the best player available and sort out positions later. The early rounds are where the gaps between players are widest, so spend those picks on value. Holes on defence and in goal are cheap to fill in the late rounds and on the waiver wire. Unless noted, every number below comes from the NHL's official stats for the 2025-26 regular season.

The most common mistake in a fantasy hockey draft is drafting for need too early. A manager takes two centres, sees an empty defence column, and grabs the best defenceman left in round three while a better forward is still on the board. It feels responsible. It usually costs points, because the early rounds are where one pick can separate you from the rest of your league, and the late rounds are where one pick barely matters.

The drop-off is steep at the top and flat at the bottom

Rank every NHL forward by points in 2025-26 and watch how fast the totals fall:

Forward rankPlayerPoints
1Connor McDavid138
12Jack Eichel90
24Mitch Marner80
60Pavel Zacha65
120Chandler Stephenson49
180Sean Monahan36

Between the 1st and the 12th forward, each step down the list cost about four points. Between the 60th and the 120th, each step cost about a quarter of a point. Sixty forwards fit inside a 16-point band in the middle of that list.

That shape is the whole case for taking the best player available. Passing on a top forward in round two to fill a position means giving up points you will not find again. Passing on a decent defenceman in round ten costs almost nothing, because the next one on the board is nearly as good.

Defencemen: draft the great ones for their points

Best player available does not mean ignoring defence. Evan Bouchard scored 95 points in 2025-26, 11th among all skaters. If he is the best player left when you pick, take him. He is worth the pick because 95 points is 95 points, and the fact that he fills a defence slot is a bonus.

What changes after the top few is how rarely defencemen score like forwards. Only 6 of the 50 highest-scoring skaters in 2025-26 were defencemen, and 16 of the top 100. Moritz Seider, the 12th-highest scoring defenceman, had 60 points, while the 60th forward had 65. Further down, the two positions look almost the same:

DefencemanPointsForwardPoints
24th (Rasmus Andersson)47150th (Ryan Hartman)43
36th (Mike Matheson)37180th (Sean Monahan)36

A defenceman you add late scores about like a forward you add late. Waiting on your depth defence costs you no more than waiting on your depth forwards, and it frees your early picks for whoever scores the most.

Defence scoring also moves around from year to year, which is one more reason not to chase a specific name to fill a slot. Of the 12 highest-scoring defencemen in 2024-25, six were back in the top 12 in 2025-26. Bouchard went from 67 points to 95. Cale Makar led all defencemen with 92 points in 2024-25 and finished third with 79 a year later. Forwards are no lock either: 14 of the top 24 forwards from 2024-25 were in the top 24 again. When every projection carries that much noise, the bigger number is the safer bet, whatever position it plays.

Goalies: the position you can fix during the season

Goaltending is where drafting for need hurts most, because goalie results are the hardest to predict.

Connor Hellebuyck won both the Hart and Vezina Trophies in 2024-25 after going 47-12-3 with a .925 save percentage. In 2025-26 he made 57 starts, won 23 and posted a .895 save percentage. Of the ten goalies with the best save percentage in 2024-25 (minimum 25 starts), only two were in the top ten again in 2025-26: Andrei Vasilevskiy and Logan Thompson. Across the 39 goalies with at least 25 starts in both seasons, the correlation between one year's save percentage and the next was 0.13. In plain terms, last season's save percentage told you almost nothing about this one.

Some of the best seasons came from goalies who were not established starters. Scott Wedgewood started 22 games in 2024-25, then led every goalie with at least 25 starts in save percentage (.921) for Colorado in 2025-26. Brandon Bussi was a waiver claim: Carolina picked him up from Florida on October 5, 2025, nine days before his NHL debut. He won 31 games, tied for fourth in the league.

The gap between starters is smaller than it looks on draft day. In 2025-26, 53 goalies made 25 or more starts. The fifth-highest win total among them was 31 and the 25th was 22, by Buffalo's Ukko-Pekka Luukkonen, whose .910 save percentage ranked sixth in that group. Draft boards have caught on: on the board we pulled on 25 September 2026, not one goalie went inside the first fifty picks.

Putting it into practice

  • Rank by value, then use position as the tiebreaker. When two players sit in the same tier and you would be equally happy with either, take the one at the thinner position. When one is clearly better, take him and move on.
  • Count your rounds against your minimums. Know your league's position limits and how many slots you still must fill. The time to draft for need is when the rounds you have left barely cover the slots you still owe. Before that, the best player wins.
  • Fill holes in the late rounds. On a ten-team best-ball board, players past roughly pick 148 are close to interchangeable. That is the cheapest place on the board to grab a third goalie or a fifth defenceman.
  • Plan to use the waiver wire. Bussi and Wedgewood both show that a starting goalie can turn up after the draft. A thin spot in October can be fixed by November, while a missed elite forward cannot.

None of this means your roster ends up lopsided. Most of the late-round and waiver fixes above are exactly how a balanced roster gets built: a core of the highest scorers you could get, with the gaps filled by players who cost you almost nothing.